I better be quick about writing this because the underlying facts probably have a short shelf life. I learn that Mr. Trump now is expressing support for NATO [hat tip Noah Milman], seems to be taking a seemingly less extremist stance stance regarding China, and seems to be distancing himself from his alt-right advisor, Steve Bannon [paywall probably applies]. Are these indications of a sometimes-discussed “pivot” toward more responsible governance?

Maybe….but we have to decide what kind of pivot we’re talking about.

Then there’s the personal pivot. This is personal change resulting from an honest self-assessment.  It can come quickly, as in a road to Damascus conversion experience. Or it can come gradually, and observable only long after the pivoting began. I don’t see any fish scales falling from Mr. Trump’s eyes, and if he is on the painful, gradual road to a personal reevaluation, we won’t know for at least a few years.

There’s the institutional pivot. This doesn’t preclude a personal change, but it relies on the sets of incentives and constraints that work on the presidency. As I have tried to argue before,

But the argument that Mr. Trump will grow into the presidency doesn’t rely only on the proposition that he’ll become a better person. It also relies on the claim that our system of checks and balances might actually work and that the federal bureaucracy will do what bureaucracies do and somehow condition what Mr. Trump can accomplish.

I’d add other factors to “checks and balances’ and “federal bureaucracy”: federalism, civil society, the press, individual acts of resistance. In this second sense, it’s possible we’re about to see a pivot.

However and as with the first sense, we probably won’t really know it’s a true pivot for several years. One reason among many I distrust Mr. Trump is that he seems to change his mind on a whim. Pivoting hither and yon from one day to the next isn’t the type of pivot I’m hoping for.

We also need to keep perspective. I think it’s a good thing that Mr. Trump seems to be (this week) distancing himself from Mr. Bannon. But he shouldn’t have hired him in the first place. He should have laughed away the suggestion when it was made. And “distancing himself from” isn’t the same as firing.

There’s finally the disturbing point that we are–or at least I am–looking for any sign of change and clinging to it, hoping it’s change for real or at least contenting ourselves that it’s not quite as bad at he moment as it seemed and may again seem at other times. Maybe the king won’t show up to parliament in his underwear. Maybe the emperor will put on some clothes for once. I suppose it’s kind of like dreading the moment an abuser comes home only to be relieved that tonight he’s in a good mood.


Category: Statehouse

About the Author

Gabriel Conroy (conroy, fka Pierre Corneille and corneille1640) is an ex-graduate student. Now he writes blogs! He has a solo blog--Ye Olde Republicke. The views expressed by Gabriel (or Pierre, or corneille1640) are his alone and do not necessarily reflect those of his spouse, employer, or his co-bloggers at Hitcoffee.

4 Responses to Auguries of a pivot?

  1. Kolohe says:

    On the other hand, the phone call to Erdogan

  2. Brandon Berg says:

    I have nothing interesting to say here, but I do have interesting things to say Over There, where my comments on the Linky Friday thread are vanishing into the ether. I don’t know if they’re getting stuck in moderation or what, but they’re not showing up, even for me right after I post them.

    • Brandon Berg says:

      Don’t know whether someone saw this and did something, or it’s just a coincidence, but it seems to be working now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

If you are interested in subscribing to new post notifications,
please enter your email address on this page.

Espresso


Recent Comments

  • Jaybird on Beer PopulismRemember this one from 1986? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6cLoTKfBs4
  • Jaybird on Beer PopulismI think it's little more than alcohol content. If you look at the ones hovering aroun…
  • Oscar Gordon on Beer PopulismI hate IPAs, I just do not get the appeal. I like a good stout, or an amber (dependin…
  • gabriel conroy on Beer PopulismYeah, I don't like IPA's either (for the same reason) I don't understand it. Sometime…
  • fillyjonk on Recursive DreamingI've had dreams where I woke up, realized what I had been dreaming was a dream, then…
  • Peter on Beer PopulismIt bothers me that most craft beers are IPA's, which are disgustingly bitter.
  • gabriel conroy on Beer PopulismIt's hard for me to balance my own reverse-snobbery with the fact that I love microbr…
  • Jon on Data Plan BluesMy father spent many years testifying in courts, town meetings, etc., as an expert wi…

Queenland

Greetings from Stonebridge a fictitious city in a fictitious state located in a tri-state area in the interior Mid-Atlantic region. We're in western Queenland, which is really a state unto itself, and not to be confused with Queensland in Australia.

Nothing written on this site should be taken as strictly true, though if the author were making it all up rest assured the main character and his life would be a lot less unremarkable.


Hit Categories


History Coffee