1/ my tardy, obligatory take on kindergarten Thermidor – this is about updating the criteria for counter-revolutionaries, not free speech
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
2/ I see some on the centre-right express sympathy for our petit Robespierre – he would guillotine you in an instant, why bother
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
3/ the reigning purge-manuals specify that you can only harass and defame people for being sexist or racist, not classist
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
4/ they simply want to add "classist" to that list, perhaps even on top of it https://t.co/MINBO8Vb6z
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
5/ the further you drift from the political center, the more you see violence as a necessity – almost no exceptions pic.twitter.com/a6UY0qyiTf
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
6/ I know this because I can relate to it personally – I'll be deliberately vague out of deference to my new followers –
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
7/ the closest intelligible analogue to Marxist bloodlust I can think of is the neoliberal relish for layoffs and offshoring
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
8/ side-suppliers see job-loss as an index of efficiency, jacobins see the heads rolling as a speedometer for the expedition of "history"
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
9/ "economic adjustment" can be horrifying for the losers – divorce, drug addiction, suicide, depression are all universal aftereffects
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
10/ the tankies see their political enemies as Objectivists see public school teachers
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
11/ if our petite Robespierre "wins," it won't be a victory for free speech, but for "class" as an axis of oppression
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
12/ which would only add a new dimension to the hypertrophic scholasticism that is contemporary identity politics discourse
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
13/ it's enticing for the right in the short term – you can use "working class" creds to stick it to the AEI crowd – but it's very dangerous
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
14/ poor whites are far from being the poorest in the world – "class" as a value could easily be twisted to support open borders
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
15/ the white working class could easily be redefined as bourgeois, for instance – only third worlders constitutes the "real" proletariat
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
16/ "white feminist," meet "first-world proletariat"
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
17/ but the main point I want to make is that civility and tolerance doesn't necessarily beget civility and tolerance
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
18/ @MattBruenig would jail his erstwhile capitalist-roader, pro-free speech defenders without a second thought, and I get that
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
19/ I'm not sentimental about the effete https://t.co/rkbdhVnbha libertarians shielding the right – on judgment day, I wouldn't hesitate–
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
20/ tl;dr whether or not "class" becomes a sacred value, free speech won't benefit; radicals feel zero gratitude toward classical liberals
— Jonathan Zhou (@Zhou___) May 23, 2016
About the Author
please enter your email address on this page.